logo

More Issues In the News

SearchRSS Feed

Sarasota Herald Tribune - 7/19/2007

State increasing penalties for environmental rule breakers

 

BY DAVID ROYSE

ASSOCIATED PRESS WRITER

var byline =""; if(byline.length > 32){ byline = byline.split("."); newByline = byline[0]+".
"+byline[1]+"."+byline[2]; document.getElementById("bylineLink1").innerHTML = newByline; }
TALLAHASSEE, Fla. -- Penalties will be increased for major environmental violations in an attempt to stop companies from thinking of low fines as simply a cost of doing business, the state's top environmental official said Wednesday.

Department of Environmental Protection Secretary Michael Sole said the stiffer penalties will be handed down by the agency for the most serious violations, likely being applied in about 10 percent of enforcement actions taken by the agency.

For example, the minimum penalty for improper storage, treatment or disposal of hazardous waste will go from $100 to $500 and the maximum will increase from $25,000 per day to $32,500 per day under the new guidelines. In a few cases, fines for such hazardous waste violations could go as high as $50,000 a day under the new rules, Sole said.

Additionally, Sole said the agency would start actually collecting true per day fines in more cases. In the past, a per day fine has often been levied on the first day of a violation, but much smaller penalties have been assessed on subsequent days until the violation stops, Sole said.

"The changes to DEP's guidelines provide a stronger deterrent for the most egregious violations, ultimately reducing the number of significant infractions that occur," Sole said in a statement released by the agency. "I want to change the idea that penalties are 'a cost of doing business,' by emphasizing the agency's tough stance against violators."

Another key difference in the way penalties will be handled involves whether a company's violation of environmental rules results in an economic benefit, Sole said. That can already be factored in when calculating a penalty, but rarely is.

From now on, such economic benefits will result in higher penalties, Sole said. For example, if starting work before completing a permit results in speeding up the opening of a new development, saving a developer $10,000, the ultimate penalty would likely go up by $10,000 to erase that savings, the agency said in its new guidelines.

Environmental activists have complained for several years that DEP's approach to enforcing pollution rules has been too lax.

"Businesses have long known that if they do pay a penalty it's going to be minimal," said Mark Ferrulo, director of the advocacy group Environment Florida. "It often pays to pollute in Florida, where it's actually cheaper to pay the fines than to invest the money in cleaning up the source of pollution."

Ferrulo said that new Gov. Charlie Crist had a strong record on the environment and on enforcing environmental laws when he was attorney general, and that he thought the current move toward tougher enforcement at DEP was partly a reflection of that.

"Environmental enforcement has always had a carrot but it's never had a stick, and I think it's great news that DEP is now going to carry a bigger stick," Ferrulo said. "Because we're talking about direct impacts on public health that many of these violations have."

Besides hazardous waste cases, new higher penalties will also be in effect in cases where violations are intentional or cases where companies are repeat violators, cases that cause what the agency considers significant harm to the environment, and violations that go on for a long time.